Table of Contents
2 July 2025 (updated) Understanding Cylinder Coating Deterioration in Early M62 V8 Engines
Early BMW E39 5 Series models equipped with V8 engines faced a significant technical challenge that could lead to catastrophic engine failure. The issue centred around Nikasil coating deterioration, a problem that primarily affected engines produced between 1992 and 1998, depending on the market.
Table: Nickasil usage in BMW engines
|
Engine |
Production Years |
Nikasil Usage Period |
|
M60 V8 |
1992 – 1996 |
Entire production (1992–1996) |
|
M52 I6 |
1995 – 1998 |
1995–March 1998 (before TU update switched to steel liners) |
|
M62 (early) |
1995 – 2005 |
Early models (1995–~1998); replaced by Alusil at TU in 1998 |
What Is Nikasil and Why Did BMW Use It?
Nikasil represents a hard nickel-silicon carbide coating applied to aluminium cylinder walls to prevent wear and provide superior heat dissipation. This technology allowed BMW to create lightweight aluminium engine blocks whilst maintaining the durability traditionally associated with cast iron cylinders. The coating offered excellent thermal conductivity and reduced friction, contributing to improved engine efficiency and performance.
BMW implemented this technology across several engine families, including the M60 V8 engines from 1993 to 1996 and some M52 six-cylinder engines produced between 1995 and 1998 outside the United States. Early M62 engine variants in the E39 5 Series also featured Nikasil-lined cylinders, though BMW later transitioned to Alusil blocks for this engine family.
The Chemical Reaction Behind Nikasil Failure
The fundamental problem arose from an unexpected chemical reaction between high-sulfur fuel and the nickel component within the Nikasil coating. During the 1990s, petrol in many regions contained sulfur levels significantly higher than today's standards, typically ranging from 500 to 1,000 parts per million (ppm).
When exposed to these high-sulfur fuels over extended periods, the nickel within the Nikasil coating began to deteriorate through a chemical process that stripped away the protective layer. This reaction exposed the underlying aluminium cylinder walls to direct contact with the piston rings, leading to rapid and irreversible wear.
-25%
Article number: 5011987001831
compared to
RRP
£22.73
£16.99
£16.99
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
-26%
Article number: 1496
compared to
RRP
£23.65
£17.49
Price per item
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
-16%
LIQUI MOLY Engine oil
5W-30, 5l
Article number: 3707
compared to
RRP
£71.35
£59.49
Price per item
£11.90
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
-25%
Article number: 15F7E5
compared to
RRP
£50.65
£37.99
£9.50
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
-23%
FEBI BILSTEIN Valve, engine block breather
with fastening/mounting material
Article number: 46303
compared to
RRP
£104.99
£80.49
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
Recognising Nikasil Wear Symptoms
Early Warning Signs
The initial symptoms of Nikasil deterioration often manifest as subtle performance issues that gradually worsen. Engine roughness during idle becomes noticeable, particularly when the engine reaches normal operating temperature. Cold starting difficulties represent another early indicator, as the worn cylinder walls struggle to maintain adequate compression for reliable ignition.
Progressive Deterioration
As the coating continues to fail, compression loss accelerates throughout the affected cylinders. Increased oil consumption becomes evident, often accompanied by blue exhaust smoke during acceleration or extended running periods. The engine may develop a distinctive metallic rattling sound, particularly pronounced during cold starts or under load.
Advanced Symptoms
In severe cases, engines may refuse to start altogether, particularly in cold weather conditions where compression requirements increase. The wear pattern typically affects multiple cylinders simultaneously, though some may deteriorate faster than others depending on various factors including fuel quality exposure and driving patterns.
Diagnostic Methods and Testing Procedures
Compression Testing
The only definitive method for diagnosing Nikasil wear involves conducting compression or leakdown tests on each cylinder. BMW technicians typically perform these tests using calibrated equipment to measure cylinder pressure at cranking speed. Healthy cylinders should maintain compression readings above 12 bar (174 psi), whilst readings below 10 bar (145 psi) indicate significant wear.
Visual Inspection Limitations
Unlike many engine problems, Nikasil deterioration cannot be reliably diagnosed through visual inspection alone. The coating failure occurs at a microscopic level, making it impossible to assess wear severity without proper testing equipment.
BMW's Engineering Response
Recognition and Action
BMW engineers identified the pattern of failures and traced the root cause to the sulfur-fuel interaction. The company's response involved replacing affected engine blocks under warranty programmes that extended coverage up to six years from the vehicle's build date, regardless of mileage in many cases.
Transition to Alusil Technology
The permanent solution involved transitioning from Nikasil to Alusil cylinder liners. Alusil technology uses a different aluminium-silicon alloy composition that resists sulfur-induced degradation whilst maintaining the thermal and weight advantages of aluminium construction. This change became standard across BMW's V8 engine production from approximately 1998 onwards.
Identifying Affected Engines
There are a few ways to identify affected engines:
Engine Block Casting Numbers
Determining whether an E39 features Nikasil or Alusil cylinder liners requires checking the engine block casting numbers. These alphanumeric codes, typically located on the engine block's side, indicate the production specifications and liner type used during manufacturing.
Production Date Considerations
Most E39 5 Series models produced after 1998 feature Alusil blocks as standard. However, some earlier production vehicles may still contain Nikasil-lined engines, particularly those manufactured during the transition period between coating technologies.
FEBI BILSTEIN Antifreeze
G11, blue, 5l, Concentrate
Article number: 22268
More
£21.99
£4.40
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
Article number: 83210398507
£19.49
£19.49
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
Article number: TE 2 70
£24.99
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
MPM Antifreeze
G11, green, 1l, Ready mixed, Amine free-Phosphate free
Article number: 83001C
More
£13.99
£13.99
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
Article number: 109220
£48.49
£9.70
for 1 litre
price incl. 20% VAT, excl. delivery costs
Prevention and Maintenance Considerations
Fuel Quality Impact
Whilst modern fuel formulations contain significantly lower sulfur content than 1990s standards, maintaining consistent fuel quality remains important for engine longevity. Using premium grade petrol from reputable suppliers helps ensure optimal engine performance and reduces the risk of chemical contamination.
Regular Oil Changes
Maintaining proper oil change intervals becomes crucial for engines with any coating system. Fresh engine oil helps remove combustion byproducts and contaminants that could accelerate wear processes. The experts from Autodoc know the right engine oil specifications for maintaining optimal engine protection in BMW V8 applications.
Key Takeaways
The Nikasil coating issue represents a significant chapter in BMW's engineering history, demonstrating how external factors like fuel composition can impact advanced materials technology. Early E39 owners should verify their engine specifications and conduct compression testing if symptoms appear. Most E39 5 Series models remain unaffected due to the transition to Alusil technology, but awareness of this issue remains important for informed ownership and maintenance decisions.
Understanding the technical background, symptoms, and solutions for Nikasil deterioration enables owners to make educated decisions about their vehicles whilst appreciating the engineering complexities involved in modern engine design.
A useful video on this topic:
